- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Author of 2020, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Author of 2018, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Author of 2017, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Author of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favoriite Australian Author of 2015, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Romance Author of 2014, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Australian Romance Author of 2013, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Winner ~ Aussie Romance Bestseller, Romance at Booktopia Australian Romance Author Month, July 2013
- Favourite Australian Romance Author of 2012, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Favourite Australian Romance Author of 2011, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Favourite Australian Romance Author of 2010, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Favourite Australian Romance Author of 2009, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Best New Author of 2007 in All About Romance Reader Poll
The Highlander’s Christmas Countess: The Lairds Most Likely Book 8
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2020, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Christmas Romance of 2020, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Highlander’s English Bride: The Lairds Most Likely Book 6
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2020, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of of 2020 (The Lairds Most Likely) , Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Highlander’s Defiant Captive: The Lairds Most Likely Book 4
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2019, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Laird’s Christmas Kiss: The Lairds Most Likely Book 2
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2018, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Laird’s Willful Lass: The Lairds Most Likely Book 1
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2018, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2018 (The Likely Lairds), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Lord Garson’s Bride: A Novel-Length Dashing Widows Romance
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2018, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2018 (Dashing Widows), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Christmas Stranger: A Regency Novella
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2017, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Strongest Heroine of 2017 (Maggie Carr) , Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Catching Captain Nash: Dashing Widows Book 6
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2017, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2017 (DashingWidows), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Charming Sir Charles: Dashing Widows Book 5
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2017, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Mistletoe and the Major: A Regency Novella
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
A Match Made in Mistletoe: A Regency Novella
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Pursuing Lord Pascal : Dashing Widows Book 4
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Stranded with the Scottish Earl: A Regency Novella
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Winning Lord West: Dashing Widows Book 3
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Tempting Mr. Townsend: Dashing Widows Book 2
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2016, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2016 (Dashing Widows), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
A Pirate for Christmas: A Regency Novella
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2015, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
The Seduction of Lord Stone: Dashing Widows Book 1
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2015, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Cover from a Romance Published in 2015, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
Her Christmas Earl: A Regency Novella
- Winner ~ Romantic Novella of the Year (the 2015 Ella), Romance Writers of Australia
- Finalist ~ Historical Category, 2016 Southern Magic Gayle Wilson Award of Excellence
- 3rd place ~ Historical Category, 2016 Mid-American Romance Authors Carla Awards
- 3rd place ~ Historical Category, 2016 New England Readers Choice Awards
- Finalist ~ Historical category, 2016 Award of Excellence, Colorado Romance Writers
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2015, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2015 (Sons of Sin), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Romantic Times Book Reviews Top Pick
- Booklist starred review
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2014, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series of 2014 (Sons of Sin), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Sexiest Hero from a Romance Published in 2014 (Camden Rothermere, Duke of Sedgemoor), Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Favorite Cover from a Romance Published in 2014, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Historical category, 2015 Booksellers Best Award, Greater Detroit Romance Writers of America
- Winner ~ Historical category, 2015 National Excellence in Romantic Fiction Award, First Coast Romance Writers of America
- Finalist ~ Historical category, 2015 Award of Excellence, Colorado Romance Writers
- Romantic Times Book Reviews Top Pick
- Booklist starred review
- Included in 2014’s top 10 romance by Booklist, the Journal of the American Library Association
- Second ~ Historical Category, Wisconsin Romance Writers of America 2014 Write Touch Readers Awards
- Finalist ~ historical romance category, 2014 National Excellence in Romance Fiction Award, First Coast Romance Writers of America
- Finalist ~ Best Historical Romance, 2014 Romance Writers of America RITA« Awards
- Finalist ~ historical category, 2014 Birmingham Southern Magic RWA Gayle Wilson Award of Excellence
- Finalist ~ Favorite Historical Romance of 2013, Australian Romance Reader Association Awards
- Winner ~ Favorite Continuing Romance Series (Sons of Sin), Australian Romance Reader Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Sexiest Hero from a romance published in 2013 (Sir Richard Harmsworth), Australian Romance Reader Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Best Sensual Historical Romance, RT Book Reviews 2013 Reviewers Choice Awards
- Romantic Times Book Reviews Top Pick
- Finalist ~ historical category, 2013 Heart of Denver Romance Writers Aspen Gold Contest
- Winner ~ historical category, 2013 Wisconsin Romance Writers of America Write Touch Readers Choice Award
- Finalist ~ historical Category, 2013 Birmingham Southern Magic Chapter Gayle Wilson Award of Excellence
- Favorite Historical Romance of 2012, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Best First Meeting Between a Couple of 2012, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Best Love Scene of 2012, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Best Cover of 2012, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Winner ~ Historical Category, 2012 Ancient City Romance Writers of America Heart of Excellence Contest
- Finalist ~ Long Romance Category, 2012 Australian Romantic Book of the Year Award (the R*BY)
- Best Historical Romance of 2011, Phoenix Desert Rose Romance Writers of America Golden Quill Awards
- Finalist ~ Historical Category, 2012 Oklahoma Romance Writers of America National Readers’ Choice Awards
- Finalist ~ Best Historical Romance of 2012, Wisconsin Romance Writers of America Write Touch Readers’ Award
- Finalist ~ Best Historical Romance of 2012, Birmingham Southern Magic Chapter Gayle Wilson Award of Excellence
- Romantic Times Book Reviews Top Pick
- Finalist ~ Best Sensual Historical Romance, Romantic Times 2011 Reviewers Choice Awards
- Favourite Historical Romance of 2011, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Winner ~ Historical category, First Coast Romance Writers 2011 Beacon Awards
- Winner ~ Historical category, 2011 Heart of Denver Romance Writers Aspen Gold Contest
- Finalist ~ Historical category, Romance Writers of Australia 20 Years of Romance Covers Showcase, 2011
- Finalist ~ Regency category, 2011 Phoenix Desert Rose Romance Writers of America Golden Quill Awards
- Favourite Historical Romance of 2010, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Romantic Times Book Reviews Top Pick
- Finalist ~ Best Sensual Historical Romance, Romantic Times 2010 Reviewers Choice Awards
- Number 8 in Kate Cuthbert’s Top 10 Romances of 2010, Australian Romance Readers Association newsletter
- Winner ~ Historical category, Ancient City Romance Authors 2010 Heart of Excellence Awards
- Finalist ~ Historical category, Georgia Romance Writers 2010 Maggie Awards
- Finalist ~ Long Historical category, Greater Detroit Romance Writers of America 2010 Booksellers Best Awards
- 2nd ~ Historical category, First Coast Romance Writers 2010 Beacon Awards
- Finalist ~ Historical Section of the Wisconsin Romance Writers of America Write Touch Readers Awards, 2010
- Finalist ~ Historical category of Southern Magic Chapter’s Gayle Wilson Award of Excellence 2010
- Romantic Times Top Pick and winner of November 2009 K.I.S.S. (Knight in Shining Silver) Award
- Featured in Publishers Weekly’s list of the 100 best books of 2009 (only one of five mass market paperbacks in the list)
- Favourite Historical Romance of 2009, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Finalist ~ Regency Romance category, 2010 Phoenix Desert Rose Romance Writers of America Golden Quill Awards
- Finalist ~ Long Historical category, 2010 RomCon Inc Readers Crown
- Best Historical Romance, 2010 Phoenix Desert Rose Romance Writers of America Golden Quill Awards
- Finalist ~ historical category, Authors After Dark 2010 Bookie Awards
- Finalist ~ Most Popular Historical Romance of 2009, Australian Romance Readers Association Awards
- Nominated as Best Sensual Historical Romance of 2009 in Romantic Times Book Reviews Reviewers’ Choice Awards.
- Romantic Times Top Pick and winner of January 2009 K.I.S.S. (Knight in Shining Silver) Award
- Best Regency Romance, 2010 Phoenix Desert Rose Romance Writers of America Golden Quill Awards
- Winner ~ historical category, Heart of Denver Romance Writers 2010 Aspen Gold Contest
- Finalist ~ Long Romance category, 2009 Romance Writers of Australia Romantic Book of the Year Award
- Favorite Historical Romance of 2008, Australian Romance Readers Association
- Second ~ Historical category, Lake Country Romance Writers Barclay Gold Awards
- Runner-Up ~ Historical category, Heart of Denver Romance Writers Aspen Gold Awards
- Romantic Times Top Pick and winner of January 2008 K.I.S.S. (Knight in Shining Silver) Award
- Finalist, Best Regency Historical Romance, 2008 Romance Writers of America RITA Awards
- Realms Shooting Star Award for a book “that changed our universe” from Realms on our Bookshelves
- Number six on Kate Cuthbert’s list of best romances of 2007, Brisbane Courier-Mail, January, 2008
- Winner of Best Long Historical Romance category, Greater Detroit Romance Writers of America 2008 Booksellers’ Best Awards.
- Finalist ~ Mainstream category, 2008 Romance Writers of Australia Romantic Book of the Year Award
- Finalist ~ Best Regency Historical Romance, 2008 Romance Writers of America RITA Awards
- Best Debut of 2007, Michelle Buonfiglio’s Lifetime TV Romance: B(u)y the Book
- Book of the Year 2007, Michelle Buonfiglio’s Lifetime TV Romance: B(u)y the Book
- Best First Single Title Romance of 2007 (Debut Author) in the Single Titles.com Readers Choice poll
- Winner of Best First Historical Romance in the Romantic Times Book Reviews Reviewers’ Choice Awards 2007